저자명 송정한 
년도 2008 
The electric resistance spot welding process is an indispensable assembling process of steel auto-panels in the automobile industries since its introduction in 1950’s. As a modern auto-body contains several thousands of spot welds, the strength of spot welds under dynamic loading conditions is extremely important in the evaluation of the integrity and crashworthiness of auto-body members. Due to the geometric complexity and material non-homogeneity factors involved in spot welds, it is impractical in auto-body crash analyses to model every spot weld accurately using detailed solid elements. Currently, in auto-body crash analyses, a common method of modeling a spot weld is to use a rigid link or a beam element. The onset of failure of a spot weld is determined using a failure model which takes into account the forces acting on the spot weld. However, the failure of a spot weld is assumed to be independent of the strain rate in the vehicle crash simulation due to the lark of both an effective testing methodology and available data to model the failure behavior of spot welds accurately. Under a rapid collapse in a crash situation, the failure behavior of a spot weld can differ substantially from a statically loaded case. The immediate implications of the quasi-static behavior of spot welds in crash analyses, thus, lead to inaccurate numerical results of the load and energy absorption of an auto-body.
This paper deals with dynamic failure of spot welds under combined axial and shear loading conditions. Quasi-static and dynamic failure tests of spot welds in three different steels of mild steel, high strength steel and advanced high strength steel (AHSS) were conducted at seven different combined loading conditions. A universal testing machine of INSTRON 4206 was used in the quasi-static failure test and a high speed material testing machine was utilized in the dynamic failure tests at the intermediate strain rate of 1/sec, 10/sec and 100/sec, as the strain rate most relevant to an automotive crash event lies in the intermediate strain rate regime. In order to obtain the failure load with the proportional loading path in terms of the axial load and the shear load, test fixtures and a specimen were newly designed and fabricated with the information from finite element analyses. The proposed apparatus guarantees a greatly improved failure mechanism from two aspects: the first involves the improved constraint condition using a pin-joint between the pull bar and the fixture; and the second involves the prevention of unfavorable rotation by the nugget using the guide plates. The proposed test fixtures and specimens make it reliable to calculate the axial and the shear failure load using simple trigonometric functions of the applied failure load and the initial loading angles.
Failure loads and failure behavior of spot welds were evaluated using the experimental data. The experimental results indicate that failure loads do not show a monotonic increase or decrease with increasing loading angles, as reported in earlier studies in the literature. The failure load decreases as the loading angle increases when the loading angle is less than 30°, whereas the failure load increases as the loading angle increases at the interval from 45° to 90°. The experiment also revealed that a spot weld fails with different failure modes as the loading angle changes. When the pure axial load acts on the spot weld at the loading angle of 0°, shear failure mode was observed around the circumferential boundary of the nugget. For combined axial and shear loading conditions, failure is initiated with the localized necking in the interface between the HAZ and the base metal. From the failure loads measured in the experiment, the failure contour of spot welds at different strain rates were constructed by decomposing the failure loads into the two components along the axial and shear directions and decomposed ones were plotted in the force domain. The failure contour of the spot weld expands with increasing strain rates.
In order to describe the failure behavior for the finite element analysis of auto-body components, a failure model has to be proposed by interpolating failure contours obtained from failure tests accurately. Although some failure models of a spot weld have been proposed in quasi-static case, relatively few studies reported regarding the failure model of a spot weld under impact loading conditions. In this paper, a dynamic failure model was newly proposed from the assumed stress field around the spot weld which satisfies the force and moment equilibrium conditions. The proposed failure criterion takes the shape of a β-norm failure contour and the strain-rate sensitivity values of the axial and shear failure load are assigned as an exponential function of the logarithm of the strain-rate. The proposed failure model provides a fairly accurate interpolation of the failure contours of spot welds obtained from the experiment at intermediate strain rates, as the axial and shear failure load are coupled using the shape parameter of β. In general case of FE analyses for welded steel structures, it is suggested that the β value of 1.45 with the axial failure load and the shear failure load obtained could be used for a failure criterion without losing the accuracy of the numerical calculation.
번호 제목 저자명 날짜 조회 수
27 Study on Dynamic Tensile Tests of Auto-body Steel Sheet at the Intermediate Strain Rate for Material Constitutive Equations (차체강판의 중변형률 속도에서의 동적 인장시험 및 물성 구성방정식에 관한 연구) 임지호  2005.11.29 27387
26 A New Ductile Fracture Criterion for the Formability Prediction of Steel Sheets and Its Application to Finite Element Analysis (강판의 성형성 예측을 위한 새로운 연성 파괴 조건 및 유한 요소 해석에의 응용) [1] Yanshan Lou  2012.12.10 23217
25 Forming Limit Diagram of Auto-body Steel Sheets at High Strain Rates for Sheet Metal Forming and Crashworthiness (박판성형 및 충돌성능 향상을 위한 고변형률속도에서의 차체강판 성형한계도) 김석봉  2010.07.13 23183
24 Analysis of Elasto-Plastic Stress Waves by a Time Discontinuous Variational Integrator of Hamiltonian with a Second-Order Integration Scheme of the Constitutive Model (해밀토니안의 시간 불연속 변분적분기와 구성방정식의 2차 정확도 적분법을 이용한 탄소 조상순  2008.12.15 23149
23 A Study on the Tension/Compression Hardening Behavior of Auto-body Steel Sheets Considering the Pre-strain and the Strain Rate (초기 변형률 및 변형률 속도를 고려한 차체 강판의 인장/압축 경화 거동에 관한 연구) [1] 배기현  2011.01.11 22494
22 A Study on Material Properties of OFHC Copper Film at High Strain Rates using High-Speed Micro Material Testing Machine (고속마이크로재료시험기를 이용한 무산소동 박판의 고변형률속도 재료물성치 연구) 김진성  2010.07.13 21963
21 Finite Element Inverse Approach and Initial Guess Generation for Sheet Metal Forming Analysis of Complicated Auto-body Members (복잡한 차체부재의 박판성형공정을 위한 유한요소 역해석 및 초기추측치 계산) 김승호  2005.11.29 20634
» A Study on the Dynamic Failure Model of a Spot Weld under Combined Loading Conditions for Auto-body Crash Analyses (차체용 부재의 충돌해석을 위한 복합하중조건에서 점용접부의 동적 파단모델 연구) [1] 송정한  2008.07.24 20490
19 Optimum Process Design in Sheet Metal Forming Processes using Finite Element Sensitivity Analysis (유한요소 민감도해석을 이용한 박판금속성형에서의 공정변수 최적설계) [1] 김세호  2005.11.29 20324
18 Strain-Rate Dependent Anisotropic Yield Criteria for Auto-body Steel Sheets (자동차용 강판의 변형률속도 의존 이방성 항복함수에 관한 연구) 허지향  2012.12.11 20030
17 Evaluation of a cast-joining process of dual metal crankshafts for heavy-duty engines with ductile cast iron and high strength forged steel(구상흑연주철과 고강도 단조강의 주조접합 이종금속을 이용한 중대형 엔진 크랭크샤프트의 평가) 한 신  2010.07.13 19385
16 Measurement Uncertainty Evaluation for High Strain Rate Tensile Properties of Auto-body Steel Sheet (자동차용 강판 고속인장물성 데이터의 측정불확도 산출) 정세환  2012.12.10 19309
15 Development of a Nonlinear Degenerated Shell Element with the Drilling Degree of Freedom by the Cubic Polynomial Interpolation and the Assumed Strain Method (드릴링 자유도의 삼차 근사법과 대체변형률법을 이용한 비선형 감절점 쉘 요소의 개발) 이형욱  2005.11.29 19213
14 Dynamic Formulation of Finite Element Limit Analysis for Impact Simulation of Structural Members (구조부재의 충돌해석을 위한 유한요소 극한해석의 동적 수식화) 김기풍  2005.11.29 19190
13 Rate Dependent Hardening Model for Pure Titanium Considering the Effect of Deformation Twinning (쌍정의 영향을 고려한 티타늄의 변형률속도 의존 경화 모델) 안광현  2012.12.12 18974
12 Microscopic investigation of the strain rate hardening for auto-body steel sheet(차체강판 변형률속도 경화의 미시적 관찰) 윤종헌  2010.07.13 18600
11 Finite Element Simulation of 3-dimensional Superplastic blow forming with diffusion bonding (유한요소법을 이용한 초소성 재료의 삼차원 확산 접합 및 압력 성형 해석) 이기석  2005.11.29 18462
10 Crash Analysis of Auto-body Structures with an Explicit Finite Element Method ( 외연적 유한요소법을 이용한 차체 구조물의 충돌해석 ) 강우종  2005.11.29 18137
9 Shell Element Formulation for Limit Analysis of Thin-Walled Structures ( 박판부재의 붕괴거동해석을 위한 극한해석의 쉘요소 수식화 ) 김현섭  2005.11.29 16258
8 A Study on a Continuum Damage Yield Function to Predict Ductile Fracture of Materials (재료의 연성파단을 예측하기 위한 연속체 손상 항복 함수에 관한 연구) 고윤기  2012.12.10 16149